Decadent Reese’s Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake with a Molten Twist

Let me tell you about the first time I made this Reeses peanut butter earthquake cake – my kitchen smelled like a candy shop and my family went absolutely wild for it! Picture this: rich chocolate cake with a molten peanut butter center that oozes out when you cut into it, dotted with melty Reese’s cups. It’s the kind of dessert that makes everyone at the table go quiet except for happy mmms and the occasional “oh wow.” The magic happens when the cake bakes up around that sweet peanut butter filling, creating those gorgeous earthquake cracks that give this beauty its name. Trust me, once you try this ridiculously easy showstopper, it’ll become your go-to dessert for every potluck and family gathering!

Why You’ll Love This Reeses Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake

Oh my goodness, where do I even start? This cake is pure magic, and here’s why you’re gonna adore it:

• Effortless baking – We’re talking box mix magic here, folks. Even my 12-year-old niece could make this (though I’d keep an eye on the peanut butter jar – she’s a sneaky little spoon-licker).
• That jaw-dropping moment when you cut into it and the warm peanut butter filling comes oozing out like edible lava. Pure dessert theater!
• Reese’s cups in every bite – because let’s be honest, chocolate and peanut butter were just meant to be together.
• Crowd-pleaser guaranteed – I’ve brought this to everything from PTA meetings to tailgates, and I always come home with an empty pan.

Seriously, this cake is like giving everyone at your table a big chocolatey hug. And who doesn’t need more of that?

Ingredients for Reeses Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake

Okay, let’s raid the pantry! Here’s everything you’ll need to create this chocolate-peanut butter masterpiece. I’m super particular about these ingredients because trust me – the quality makes all the difference in this cake.

• 1 box (15.25 oz) chocolate cake mix – Devil’s food works best, but any chocolate variety will do in a pinch
• 1 cup water – Room temp is ideal for smooth mixing
• 1/2 cup vegetable oil – Or swap with melted coconut oil if you’re feeling fancy
• 3 large eggs – Cracked right from the fridge is fine, no need to wait for room temp
• 1 cup creamy peanut butter – Not the natural kind! We need that stabilizer magic from regular PB
• 1 cup powdered sugar – Sift it if yours is lumpy
• 1/2 cup whole milk – The fat content helps create that dreamy filling texture
• 1 cup Reese’s peanut butter cups, chopped into quarters – Miniatures work great, no unwrapping needed!
• 1/2 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips – Because more chocolate is always the right answer

Quick tip: Measure your peanut butter in a liquid measuring cup sprayed with cooking spray – it’ll slide right out without sticking! Oh, and hide those Reese’s cups until mixing time unless you want “helpers” nibbling away your ingredients. (Learned that one the hard way with my cookie-baking crew.)

How to Make Reeses Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake

Alright, let’s get to the fun part! Making this cake is easier than you think, but I’ll walk you through each step so it comes out perfect every time. Just follow along and resist the urge to peek in the oven too often – that heat needs to work its magic!

Preparing the Cake Batter

First things first – preheat that oven to 350°F (175°C) and grab your 9×13-inch baking pan. Give it a good spray with nonstick spray or rub it down with butter – we don’t want any of this deliciousness sticking!

Now, in a large bowl (I use my favorite blue mixing bowl – don’t ask me why, but everything tastes better when I use it), combine the chocolate cake mix, water, vegetable oil, and eggs. Mix with a hand mixer or whisk just until everything’s smooth and combined – about 2 minutes max. Don’t go crazy with the mixing though! Overmixed batter makes for a tough cake, and we want this baby tender and moist.

Layering the Peanut Butter Filling

Here’s where the magic happens! Pour half of that gorgeous chocolate batter into your prepared pan. Now, in another bowl, mix together the peanut butter, powdered sugar, and milk until it’s smooth and dreamy. Drop spoonfuls of this peanut butter goodness all over the chocolate batter – don’t worry about being perfect, those random dollops will create the best “earthquake” effect!

Gently pour the remaining chocolate batter over the top, then take a butter knife and make some lazy figure-eights through the batter to swirl things a bit. Don’t overdo it – we want pockets of that peanut butter surprise! Finally, scatter those chopped Reese’s cups and chocolate chips across the top like you’re decorating the best birthday cake ever.

Baking and Finishing Touches

Pop that beauty in the oven and set your timer for 30 minutes. When the buzzer goes, check it – the edges should be set and pulling slightly away from the pan, but the center should still have a slight jiggle when you gently shake the pan. That jiggle means gooey perfection inside! If it’s still super wobbly, give it another 3-5 minutes, but no more – we’re not making cake jerky here.

Let it cool for about 15 minutes before cutting (I know, the wait is torture!). The cake will keep baking a bit from residual heat, and that peanut butter filling needs time to set up just enough so it oozes rather than gushes when you slice it. Not that gushing is bad… but we want that perfect Instagram-worthy flow, right?

Tips for the Best Reeses Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake

After making this cake more times than I can count (my neighbors start dropping hints when it’s been too long!), I’ve picked up some foolproof tricks to make sure yours turns out perfect every single time:

• The jiggle test is your best friend – Pull the cake when the center still wobbles slightly like jello. It’ll keep setting as it cools, and that’s how you get that dreamy molten center.
• Chop those Reese’s cups small – I like quartered mini cups because they distribute evenly without sinking. Big chunks make slicing messy!
• Room temp peanut butter mixes smoother – If yours is fridge-cold, microwave it for 10 seconds before making the filling. But watch it – melted PB turns greasy!
• Undermix the batter – Stir just until the flour disappears. A few tiny lumps are better than developing too much gluten (which makes cake tough).
• Let it rest before cutting – I know it’s hard to wait, but 15 minutes lets the filling set just enough for picture-perfect slices that still ooze beautifully.

Bonus tip from my last bake sale disaster: If your peanut butter filling sinks (it happens to the best of us!), just call it a “chocolate peanut butter pudding cake” and watch it disappear just as fast. Some of my happiest kitchen accidents turned into family favorites!

Ingredient Substitutions and Notes

Okay, let’s talk swaps and special notes – because sometimes you’re staring into your pantry thinking “Can I make this work?” The answer is usually yes, with a few caveats!

Peanut Butter Alternatives

While I’m forever loyal to classic peanut butter in this recipe (that stabilizer magic creates the perfect texture), I’ve tested alternatives when my niece with allergies visits:

• Almond butter works beautifully but use slightly less (about 3/4 cup) since it’s oilier
• Sunflower seed butter gives that nutty vibe without actual nuts – just expect a greener tint!
• Cookie butter makes an insanely decadent twist (reduce powdered sugar to 3/4 cup)

Important: Natural peanut butter can work if you stir it really well first, but the filling might be runnier. If you go this route, chill the peanut butter mixture for 15 minutes before layering.

Cake Mix Options

The box mix shortcut is what makes this recipe so magical, but here’s the scoop if you need alternatives:

• Gluten-free cake mix works perfectly – just check the box for same measurements
• Homemade chocolate cake batter needs about 4 cups total – use your favorite recipe!
• Try devil’s food for extra richness if your store has multiple chocolate options

Other Handy Swaps

Ran out of something? No panic!

• Milk: Any percentage works, but skim will make the filling less creamy
• Eggs: Flax eggs (1 tbsp ground flax + 3 tbsp water per egg) work in a pinch
• Toppings: No Reese’s? Chop up peanut butter cups or swirl in extra peanut butter!

One last pro tip: If you’re using a glass pan, reduce oven temp by 25°F. Glass conducts heat differently than metal and can make edges overbake before the center sets. Learned that the hard way when my first attempt came out with crispy edges and soup in the middle!

Serving and Storing Reeses Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake

Ohhh boy, this is where things get really good! The absolute BEST way to serve this cake? Warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream melting over the top. That cold ice cream hitting the warm peanut butter filling? Pure magic. I like to cut generous squares and let everyone add their own scoop – my kids call it “building their dessert volcano.”

Leftovers (ha! as if!) keep beautifully at room temperature for about 2 days if you cover the pan tightly with foil or plastic wrap. The peanut butter filling stays gloriously gooey – just pop individual slices in the microwave for 15 seconds to bring back that fresh-from-the-oven warmth.

If you need to keep it longer, stash it in the fridge for up to 5 days. The texture changes slightly when chilled (the filling firms up), but a quick zap in the microwave fixes everything. Pro tip: Sprinkle a few extra chocolate chips on top before reheating for that just-baked look!

And yes, you can freeze this cake! Wrap individual portions tightly in plastic wrap then foil, and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge, then warm gently in the oven or microwave. My freezer always has a few emergency slices hidden behind the frozen peas – for those days when only chocolate and peanut butter therapy will do.

Reeses Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake Nutritional Information

Now, let’s be real – we’re not eating this cake for its health benefits, but I know some of you like to track these things (or need to justify that second slice to your fitness tracker!). Here’s the nutritional scoop – just remember these are estimates and will vary based on your exact ingredients and slice size.

• Serving Size: 1 slice (about 1/12 of the cake)
• Calories: 380 (worth every single one!)
• Total Fat: 20g (includes 6g saturated fat from all that peanut butter and chocolate goodness)
• Carbohydrates: 45g (28g from sugars – it is dessert after all!)
• Fiber: 2g (thanks to those peanut butter cups!)
• Protein: 7g (peanut butter packs a protein punch)
• Sodium: 320mg (mostly from the cake mix – check your brand if watching sodium)

Quick note: These numbers assume you’re using regular peanut butter and standard cake mix. If you use reduced-fat versions or sugar alternatives, your counts will be different. And let’s be honest – when you add that scoop of vanilla ice cream, all nutritional bets are off… but sometimes you just gotta live a little!

For my fellow calorie-counters, I’ve found that cutting slightly smaller slices (more like 1/16 of the cake) still satisfies the craving while trimming about 50 calories. Or just take that middle piece with extra gooey filling and enjoy every last bite – balance is everything, right?

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this earthquake cake ahead of time?

Absolutely! I actually think it tastes even better the next day when the flavors have really melded together. Just bake as directed, let it cool completely, then cover tightly with foil. It’ll keep at room temperature for up to 2 days. When ready to serve, pop individual slices in the microwave for about 15 seconds to get that warm, gooey center again. Perfect for stress-free entertaining!

Can I freeze leftover peanut butter earthquake cake?

You bet! This cake freezes like a dream. Let it cool completely, then cut into portions. Wrap each piece tightly in plastic wrap, then foil to prevent freezer burn. It’ll keep for up to 3 months in the freezer. When the craving hits (because it will!), just thaw overnight in the fridge or microwave straight from frozen for about 45 seconds. My freezer stash has saved me from many a last-minute “I need dessert now” emergency!

Why did my peanut butter filling sink to the bottom?

Oh honey, we’ve all been there! Usually this happens if the batter was too thin (maybe from overmixing) or the filling was too warm when added. Next time, try chilling your peanut butter mixture for about 15 minutes before layering, and don’t overmix the cake batter. But here’s a secret – even when it sinks, it still tastes AMAZING. Just call it a “peanut butter pudding cake” and watch it disappear just as fast!

Can I use natural peanut butter in this recipe?

You can, but with a few tweaks. Natural peanut butter tends to be runnier, so I recommend stirring it really well, then chilling it for at least 30 minutes before mixing with the powdered sugar. You might also want to reduce the milk to 1/4 cup. The texture will be slightly different, but still delicious! Personally, I stick with regular peanut butter for this recipe because it gives that perfect thick, creamy filling consistency.

What’s the best way to serve this cake?

Warm with vanilla ice cream – no contest! The contrast of cold creamy ice cream melting into that warm peanut butter filling is pure magic. For extra decadence, drizzle some chocolate syrup on top and sprinkle with chopped peanuts. And don’t forget to gather everyone around for that first slice – watching that peanut butter lava flow out is half the fun! Leftovers (if you have any) are perfect for breakfast with your coffee. I won’t tell!

Try This Reeses Peanut Butter Earthquake Cake Today!

Alright, my fellow dessert lovers – it’s time to get baking! This Reeses peanut butter earthquake cake is seriously one of those magical recipes that looks like you spent hours in the kitchen when really, it comes together in no time. I want to see your creations! Snap a pic of that gorgeous oozy center (bonus points if you catch the moment someone’s eyes light up at first bite) and share it with me in the comments below. Did you add extra Reese’s cups? Try it with cookie butter instead of peanut butter? I want to hear all your delicious twists!

And hey – if this becomes your new go-to dessert like it has for me, do me a favor and share the recipe with that friend who’s always begging you to bring dessert to gatherings. Let’s spread the chocolate-peanut butter joy! Now go preheat that oven – your future self (and everyone at your table) will thank you.

Print